Subscribe to the CT4F Newsletter to stay informed!

Conversion Truth for Families: Mother and father sitting between teen daughter at a therapist's office

/

Padres

Did I Cause This? Addressing a Common Question from Christian Fathers

PFLAG's guide for families states plainly that nothing a parent did made their child gay or transgender, and that no valid research shows parenting style shapes who a child is attracted to or how they see themselves.

PFLAG's guide for families states plainly that nothing a parent did made their child gay or transgender, and that no valid research shows parenting style shapes who a child is attracted to or how they see themselves. The idea that a father's mistakes caused this comes from old, discredited theories that blamed family life, and "conversion therapy" was built on them. Those theories did real damage. They taught children that their parents had broken them, and they taught fathers to carry guilt that was never theirs. You did not cause this. What you do next, though, matters a great deal. A father who stays close can protect his child, while blame and pressure push a child away.

Quick Takeaways

  • Research does not support the idea that parenting makes a child gay or transgender.

  • Theories blaming family life are discredited, yet "conversion therapy" still leans on them.

  • Blaming parents can damage the relationships that protect a child.

  • Christian fathers have found a way to hold their faith and their child together.

Where the Question Comes From

Many dads ask this quietly. Was I too busy? Too hard on him? Not there enough for her? CT4F's parent-to-parent script lists "Guilt that somehow this is your fault" among the most common feelings parents describe.

That guilt did not appear out of nowhere. CT4F's history of conversion therapy notes that Irving Bieber and colleagues, in a 1962 study of 106 gay men in psychoanalysis, "concluded that homosexuality resulted from pathological family dynamics." CT4F's guide to what conversion therapy is explains that today's talk-based programs still go looking for "root causes," such as "childhood trauma, parental relationships, or peer experiences."

What the Research Says

PFLAG's Our Children guide addresses the question directly. It tells parents that nothing they or anyone else did caused it, and it states, "There is no valid research from any mainstream or scientifically sound source," showing that parenting style affects who a child is attracted to or how they see themselves. Psychologist Diane Ehrensaft adds that "parents don't make their children's gender, the children do."

The American Psychological Association's 2009 task force also found insufficient evidence that change efforts work. If you did not cause this, no program can undo it by fixing you or your child.

What Blame Costs a Family

Dr. Matt Salmon, now a psychiatrist, went through "conversion therapy" himself. In his story on CT4F, he says, "Conversion therapy asserted that my parents were to blame for me being broken." He adds, "And that caused me to resent my parents for years." CT4F draws the lesson: "Assigning that blame injures the relationships that could otherwise protect a young person."

A solution that divides families is not a solution at all.

What Christian Fathers Have Learned

  • Brandon Boulware, a Missouri lawyer and son of a Methodist minister, once pushed his daughter into boys' clothes and sports, partly to shield himself from hard questions. "I was teaching her to deny who she is," he said in his CT4F story. He says now, "The God I believe in does not make mistakes."

  • Don Rogers, a fourth-generation Southern Baptist from Texas, writes in PFLAG's guide that he "was devastated" when his son said he was gay. He later wrote, "Ultimately, I realized that I could reconcile my son and my faith."

  • An anonymous father in the same guide remembers his son saying, "Dad, I'm the same person I was before." The father reflected, "It was my perception of him that changed."

What a Father Can Do Now

  • Set down the guilt. You did not cause this, and carrying blame will not help your child.

  • Show up. Your steady presence protects your child more than any program could. Families, not counselors, know what is best for their children.

  • Refuse anyone selling a fix. A Family Acceptance Project study found parents who try to change a child "may be motivated by attempts to 'protect'" them, yet suicide attempts more than doubled among young adults whose parents tried.


Frequently Asked Questions

Did I cause my son or daughter to be gay or transgender?

No. PFLAG states that no valid research shows parenting style affects who a child is attracted to or how they see themselves.

Is it true that a distant father causes same-sex attraction?

No. Older theories blamed "pathological family dynamics," but research does not show that parenting shapes who a child is attracted to.

Why do Christian fathers feel guilty when a child comes out?

Older theories, and some practitioners today, blamed parents for a child's feelings. That teaching is discredited, and it harms fathers and children alike.

Can conversion therapy fix what a parent did wrong?

No. The APA found insufficient evidence that change efforts work, and blaming parents can damage the bond a child needs most.

How can a Christian father support a gay or transgender child?

Let go of blame, stay present, listen, and say no to anyone promising change. Fathers like Brandon Boulware and Don Rogers have kept both faith and family.

Sources and Further Reading

Research and Medical Guidance

Stories From Families

CT4F Resources for Families

Conversion Truth for Families: Mother and father sitting between teen daughter at a therapist's office

Conversion Truth for Families: Mother and father sitting between teen daughter at a therapist's office

/

Padres

Did I Cause This? Addressing a Common Question from Christian Fathers

PFLAG's guide for families states plainly that nothing a parent did made their child gay or transgender, and that no valid research shows parenting style shapes who a child is attracted to or how they see themselves.

PFLAG's guide for families states plainly that nothing a parent did made their child gay or transgender, and that no valid research shows parenting style shapes who a child is attracted to or how they see themselves. The idea that a father's mistakes caused this comes from old, discredited theories that blamed family life, and "conversion therapy" was built on them. Those theories did real damage. They taught children that their parents had broken them, and they taught fathers to carry guilt that was never theirs. You did not cause this. What you do next, though, matters a great deal. A father who stays close can protect his child, while blame and pressure push a child away.

Quick Takeaways

  • Research does not support the idea that parenting makes a child gay or transgender.

  • Theories blaming family life are discredited, yet "conversion therapy" still leans on them.

  • Blaming parents can damage the relationships that protect a child.

  • Christian fathers have found a way to hold their faith and their child together.

Where the Question Comes From

Many dads ask this quietly. Was I too busy? Too hard on him? Not there enough for her? CT4F's parent-to-parent script lists "Guilt that somehow this is your fault" among the most common feelings parents describe.

That guilt did not appear out of nowhere. CT4F's history of conversion therapy notes that Irving Bieber and colleagues, in a 1962 study of 106 gay men in psychoanalysis, "concluded that homosexuality resulted from pathological family dynamics." CT4F's guide to what conversion therapy is explains that today's talk-based programs still go looking for "root causes," such as "childhood trauma, parental relationships, or peer experiences."

What the Research Says

PFLAG's Our Children guide addresses the question directly. It tells parents that nothing they or anyone else did caused it, and it states, "There is no valid research from any mainstream or scientifically sound source," showing that parenting style affects who a child is attracted to or how they see themselves. Psychologist Diane Ehrensaft adds that "parents don't make their children's gender, the children do."

The American Psychological Association's 2009 task force also found insufficient evidence that change efforts work. If you did not cause this, no program can undo it by fixing you or your child.

What Blame Costs a Family

Dr. Matt Salmon, now a psychiatrist, went through "conversion therapy" himself. In his story on CT4F, he says, "Conversion therapy asserted that my parents were to blame for me being broken." He adds, "And that caused me to resent my parents for years." CT4F draws the lesson: "Assigning that blame injures the relationships that could otherwise protect a young person."

A solution that divides families is not a solution at all.

What Christian Fathers Have Learned

  • Brandon Boulware, a Missouri lawyer and son of a Methodist minister, once pushed his daughter into boys' clothes and sports, partly to shield himself from hard questions. "I was teaching her to deny who she is," he said in his CT4F story. He says now, "The God I believe in does not make mistakes."

  • Don Rogers, a fourth-generation Southern Baptist from Texas, writes in PFLAG's guide that he "was devastated" when his son said he was gay. He later wrote, "Ultimately, I realized that I could reconcile my son and my faith."

  • An anonymous father in the same guide remembers his son saying, "Dad, I'm the same person I was before." The father reflected, "It was my perception of him that changed."

What a Father Can Do Now

  • Set down the guilt. You did not cause this, and carrying blame will not help your child.

  • Show up. Your steady presence protects your child more than any program could. Families, not counselors, know what is best for their children.

  • Refuse anyone selling a fix. A Family Acceptance Project study found parents who try to change a child "may be motivated by attempts to 'protect'" them, yet suicide attempts more than doubled among young adults whose parents tried.


Frequently Asked Questions

Did I cause my son or daughter to be gay or transgender?

No. PFLAG states that no valid research shows parenting style affects who a child is attracted to or how they see themselves.

Is it true that a distant father causes same-sex attraction?

No. Older theories blamed "pathological family dynamics," but research does not show that parenting shapes who a child is attracted to.

Why do Christian fathers feel guilty when a child comes out?

Older theories, and some practitioners today, blamed parents for a child's feelings. That teaching is discredited, and it harms fathers and children alike.

Can conversion therapy fix what a parent did wrong?

No. The APA found insufficient evidence that change efforts work, and blaming parents can damage the bond a child needs most.

How can a Christian father support a gay or transgender child?

Let go of blame, stay present, listen, and say no to anyone promising change. Fathers like Brandon Boulware and Don Rogers have kept both faith and family.

Sources and Further Reading

Research and Medical Guidance

Stories From Families

CT4F Resources for Families

Conversion Truth for Families: Mother and father sitting between teen daughter at a therapist's office

Conversion Truth for Families: Mother and father sitting between teen daughter at a therapist's office

/

Padres

Did I Cause This? Addressing a Common Question from Christian Fathers

PFLAG's guide for families states plainly that nothing a parent did made their child gay or transgender, and that no valid research shows parenting style shapes who a child is attracted to or how they see themselves.

PFLAG's guide for families states plainly that nothing a parent did made their child gay or transgender, and that no valid research shows parenting style shapes who a child is attracted to or how they see themselves. The idea that a father's mistakes caused this comes from old, discredited theories that blamed family life, and "conversion therapy" was built on them. Those theories did real damage. They taught children that their parents had broken them, and they taught fathers to carry guilt that was never theirs. You did not cause this. What you do next, though, matters a great deal. A father who stays close can protect his child, while blame and pressure push a child away.

Quick Takeaways

  • Research does not support the idea that parenting makes a child gay or transgender.

  • Theories blaming family life are discredited, yet "conversion therapy" still leans on them.

  • Blaming parents can damage the relationships that protect a child.

  • Christian fathers have found a way to hold their faith and their child together.

Where the Question Comes From

Many dads ask this quietly. Was I too busy? Too hard on him? Not there enough for her? CT4F's parent-to-parent script lists "Guilt that somehow this is your fault" among the most common feelings parents describe.

That guilt did not appear out of nowhere. CT4F's history of conversion therapy notes that Irving Bieber and colleagues, in a 1962 study of 106 gay men in psychoanalysis, "concluded that homosexuality resulted from pathological family dynamics." CT4F's guide to what conversion therapy is explains that today's talk-based programs still go looking for "root causes," such as "childhood trauma, parental relationships, or peer experiences."

What the Research Says

PFLAG's Our Children guide addresses the question directly. It tells parents that nothing they or anyone else did caused it, and it states, "There is no valid research from any mainstream or scientifically sound source," showing that parenting style affects who a child is attracted to or how they see themselves. Psychologist Diane Ehrensaft adds that "parents don't make their children's gender, the children do."

The American Psychological Association's 2009 task force also found insufficient evidence that change efforts work. If you did not cause this, no program can undo it by fixing you or your child.

What Blame Costs a Family

Dr. Matt Salmon, now a psychiatrist, went through "conversion therapy" himself. In his story on CT4F, he says, "Conversion therapy asserted that my parents were to blame for me being broken." He adds, "And that caused me to resent my parents for years." CT4F draws the lesson: "Assigning that blame injures the relationships that could otherwise protect a young person."

A solution that divides families is not a solution at all.

What Christian Fathers Have Learned

  • Brandon Boulware, a Missouri lawyer and son of a Methodist minister, once pushed his daughter into boys' clothes and sports, partly to shield himself from hard questions. "I was teaching her to deny who she is," he said in his CT4F story. He says now, "The God I believe in does not make mistakes."

  • Don Rogers, a fourth-generation Southern Baptist from Texas, writes in PFLAG's guide that he "was devastated" when his son said he was gay. He later wrote, "Ultimately, I realized that I could reconcile my son and my faith."

  • An anonymous father in the same guide remembers his son saying, "Dad, I'm the same person I was before." The father reflected, "It was my perception of him that changed."

What a Father Can Do Now

  • Set down the guilt. You did not cause this, and carrying blame will not help your child.

  • Show up. Your steady presence protects your child more than any program could. Families, not counselors, know what is best for their children.

  • Refuse anyone selling a fix. A Family Acceptance Project study found parents who try to change a child "may be motivated by attempts to 'protect'" them, yet suicide attempts more than doubled among young adults whose parents tried.


Frequently Asked Questions

Did I cause my son or daughter to be gay or transgender?

No. PFLAG states that no valid research shows parenting style affects who a child is attracted to or how they see themselves.

Is it true that a distant father causes same-sex attraction?

No. Older theories blamed "pathological family dynamics," but research does not show that parenting shapes who a child is attracted to.

Why do Christian fathers feel guilty when a child comes out?

Older theories, and some practitioners today, blamed parents for a child's feelings. That teaching is discredited, and it harms fathers and children alike.

Can conversion therapy fix what a parent did wrong?

No. The APA found insufficient evidence that change efforts work, and blaming parents can damage the bond a child needs most.

How can a Christian father support a gay or transgender child?

Let go of blame, stay present, listen, and say no to anyone promising change. Fathers like Brandon Boulware and Don Rogers have kept both faith and family.

Sources and Further Reading

Research and Medical Guidance

Stories From Families

CT4F Resources for Families

La Verdad sobre la Conversión para Familias es un conjunto de recursos para padres y cuidadores que buscan alternativas a la terapia de conversión y necesitan una guía para afrontar los desafíos con fe y claridad.

Encuéntranos en

La Verdad sobre la Conversión para Familias es un conjunto de recursos para padres y cuidadores que buscan alternativas a la terapia de conversión y necesitan una guía para afrontar los desafíos con fe y claridad.

Encuéntranos en

La Verdad sobre la Conversión para Familias es un conjunto de recursos para padres y cuidadores que buscan alternativas a la terapia de conversión y necesitan una guía para afrontar los desafíos con fe y claridad.

Encuéntranos en